Choosing eight records for a desert island sounds straightforward until you try it. I have eleven contenders and have already become rather defensive about the prospect of losing any of them. This is entirely hypothetical, I should add; no invitation from Desert Island Discs has arrived. But the exercise is an interesting one. Ask yourself which music you would take, and you soon find yourself thinking about people, places and earlier versions of yourself.
These would not necessarily be my eleven favourite recordings in any order. They are pieces I would want to spend time with, and which offer different ways into the story of my life. Some connections are immediate; others become apparent only when I stop to consider why a particular song belongs on the list.
Dancing Queen — ABBA
There must be room for enjoyment. Writing about being gay can become so concerned with prejudice, campaigning and progress that it leaves out the considerable pleasure of being yourself.
I have been out since my teens, with supportive parents and a supportive brother. That did not remove the difficulties of being a gay teacher during the Section 28 years, or the awkward conversations that came with holding senior roles in Scouting. But neither did those difficulties consume my life. There have been friendships, laughter, love and plenty of fun. ABBA earns its place without having to shoulder a policy argument.
Love Can Build a Bridge — The Judds
Uganda comes to mind here. I first went there to help establish a partnership between British Scouts, Ugandan Scouts and UNICEF, working on immunisation, HIV awareness and peer education. I returned to train teachers and to volunteer in a refugee camp near the Rwandan border. Along the way, a country I had known very little about became somewhere full of friends.
Years later, I publicly challenged anti-gay legislation sponsored by the chairman of Uganda’s national Scout board. I also argued against severing international Scouting relationships that benefited its young people. Those friendships mattered, particularly when the conversations became difficult. A bridge needs to be strong enough for people to disagree across it.
Bless the Broken Road — Rascal Flatts
This is where I think about Mark, and the life we have together. Looking backwards can make a life appear more orderly than it felt while you were living it. You can trace connections, identify turning points and give the impression that there was a plan.
Mine has involved actor training, teaching, headship, youth charities, international work and eventually Cats Protection. Much of it followed from accepting an invitation or trusting somebody who thought I might be capable of something. I could hardly have predicted the whole journey. I am very glad it brought me here, sharing a home with Mark and a cat who has strong views about how we should spend our evenings.
Morningtown Ride — The Seekers
This takes the list towards childhood and family. When you have spent years writing biographies for conference programmes, it is easy to begin your own story with your first job. But the people who knew you before you had a business card usually have a rather different account.
I think of growing up in Gloucestershire, and of Mum sending me to Scouts in Stroud when I was eleven while my brother went to Cubs. An ordinary parental decision began something that would shape much of my life. Neither she nor I could have known that at the time. I was simply going to Scouts.
Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika — The Kenyan Boys Choir
I remember arriving at Entebbe on my first visit to Uganda: broken airport windows, armed guards and then the early-morning drive towards Kampala, passing children in brightly coloured school uniforms. I remember the heat and the smell of earth and charcoal smoke.
Later visits brought experiences that challenged me far more deeply. Teaching in Jinja and working in a refugee camp changed my understanding of how profoundly opportunity depends on circumstances beyond a person’s control. I met people whose determination and ability deserved opportunities that were simply unavailable to them.
Much later, in Nairobi’s Langata women’s prison, a young woman working towards her Gold Award handed me her speech and asked me to carry a message to the President. She had been surprised that an opportunity offered to other young people was available to prisoners. I still think about that expectation, and what it tells us about whose future we consider worth investing in.
A Song of Gloucestershire — Johnny Coppin
Home deserves a record of its own. Gloucestershire holds the landscape of my childhood, my schooldays and my first small adventures.
On an early Scout hike, wearing boots bought slightly too large, I was entrusted with the map and got us lost. My Patrol Leader helped us find our way home. Years later, I used that memory in my election speech to the World Scout Conference. By then I had travelled a long way from Stroud, but I was still drawing on something learned close to home: how much difference it makes when somebody helps you without making you feel foolish.
There are worse foundations for a life in education.
Underneath the Stars — Kate Rusby
This offers space for the quieter side of being outdoors: companionship, evenings away and the conversations that happen once the day’s activity is finished. My own Gold Award expedition took me from Hadrian’s Wall to Kielder. Years later, I was trekking in Nepal with young Award participants.
A week after I returned from Nepal, the earthquake struck. Places we had just visited were devastated, and we waited for news of people we had come to know. I was running the London Marathon the following morning; it became an emergency fundraiser. During the race, I kept thinking about our friends, their homes, the monasteries and the prayer flags.
Travel brings responsibilities with its pleasures. Once you know people somewhere, a disaster ceases to be a distant headline.
Share Love — Alexia’s recording
I think here about care made practical. In 1987, Christopher, a boy in my class, barricaded himself in his family’s flat after throwing its contents out of the window. He told the police he would only come out if I was there to make sure nobody hurt him. My headteacher took my class; I took his favourite picture book and sat outside until he joined me.
That memory has stayed with me through every subsequent job. Christopher trusted me, and I had to turn up.
Care for animals belongs in this part of my life too. Mark and I adopted Blenheim after our much-loved white rescue cat, Mo, was killed in a road traffic accident in the village. Losing Mo was heartbreaking. I know the companionship cats bring and the gap they leave behind.
My commitment to their welfare began long before it became my job. Their wellbeing matters in its own right; sharing our lives with them also makes our responsibility wonderfully immediate. Blenheim’s needs include, apparently, having Mark fill the ensuite sink so that he can drink there. Understanding another creature sometimes involves accepting that your perfectly reasonable arrangements have been rejected.
Waiting for the Great Leap Forwards — Billy Bragg
There was always going to be some politics. I have spent much of my working life concerned with who gets heard, who gets an opportunity and whose needs are overlooked.
Sometimes that has involved public campaigning. Often it has meant committee papers, patient persuasion and asking an institution to apply its own principles consistently. Helping write Scouting’s first equal opportunities policy mattered to me because I knew something of the experience of being gay within institutions that were not always comfortable with it.
Patience is useful in that work, although mine has occasionally been in short supply. I remain suspicious of being told that change must wait when the people bearing the consequences have already waited quite long enough.
Lord of the Dance — Ronan Hardiman
Energy, theatre and the pleasure of performance deserve their place. I trained as an actor before becoming a teacher; holding an audience’s attention has remained a useful skill.
There is also some amusement in choosing this recording when my enthusiasm for movement considerably exceeds my coordination. My school music teacher tried to teach me the drums. His efforts were admirable; the results were limited.
I wasn’t diagnosed with dyspraxia until my mid-thirties. Suddenly, difficulties I had treated as personal failings began to make sense. That understanding changed how I thought about my childhood and about asking young people to try harder. Effort matters, but adults need to understand what makes a task difficult before deciding that effort is what is missing.
Who Would True Valour See — Maddy Prior & The Carnival Band
Faith and persistence belong somewhere in this selection. So does the question of what you are prepared to stand up for when doing so becomes uncomfortable.
For years, I seemed to be the youngest this or the youngest that. I became a headteacher at 28 because people trusted me with responsibility. Now I find myself among the charity sector’s older statespersons, which has crept up on me rather unfairly.
“Lead, follow, and then get out of the way” has become my guiding principle. Scouting taught me to lead and to follow someone who knew more than I did. Teaching gave me the pleasure of seeing somebody manage without my help. I owe others the opportunities I was given; knowing when to hand over is part of that responsibility.
Resisting the temptation to offer a running commentary from the sidelines remains a work in progress.
I would want all eleven recordings on the island. They would give me home, love, friendship, a few arguments and something to dance to, however badly. Choosing which three to leave behind can wait until somebody actually asks.
