| |

Charity needs more than goodwill

Jodie Lloyd-Jones, the chief executive of Oxfordshire Youth, wrote a LinkedIn post today arguing that the charity sector should not have to apologise for the cost of being effective. I chair Oxfordshire Youth as a volunteer, so I have an obvious interest in what she has to say. But the discussion beneath her post deserves attention well beyond our own organisation.

Much of it will be familiar to anyone working in a charity: frustration at being expected to deliver exceptional services while apologising for employing the people and maintaining the systems that make those services possible. There was also a challenge from those running much smaller organisations, who feel overlooked in a funding landscape where larger charities have greater visibility and more resources to make their case. Both deserve a thoughtful hearing.

I recognise that I am one of the highest-paid charity chief executives in the country, and that this brings a particular responsibility to explain and account for the work I do. I have more than 25 years’ experience as a CEO. Cats Protection, the charity I lead, has a turnover of more than £100 million, employs around 1,000 staff and works with more than 10,000 volunteers. Those facts provide context for my salary; they do not put it beyond scrutiny.

I am quite often called out on social media by people who find my salary unacceptable. Some object to the amount; others to the fact that I am paid at all. Cats Protection is compared unfavourably with small animal welfare and rehoming charities managed entirely by volunteers, as though the absence of a payroll settled the question of which organisation deserved support.

I have considerable respect for those charities and the people who sustain them. Their work deserves recognition in its own right. But using their staffing arrangements as evidence against ours is unfair to both. It overlooks the different scale and scope of our responsibilities, while reducing their achievements to the fact that nobody takes a salary. Their value lies in the animals they help, the knowledge they bring and the communities they serve. Ours should be judged with the same attention to what we achieve and what it reasonably takes to achieve it.

An organisation with no paid staff still depends on work being done; the people doing it contribute its cost through their unpaid time and expertise. That can be a very effective way to organise a charity. It does not follow that the same arrangements could sustain a national network with our responsibilities, or that employing people makes us less deserving of trust. Some of the criticism seems to rest on a limited understanding of what running either kind of organisation actually involves. We have a responsibility to explain that more clearly, but a fair comparison needs more than a glance at the salary bill.

Calling me a “fat cat”, as some people have predictably done on social media, has an irony which, given my employer, is difficult to resist. As an argument, however, it is fatuous. It tells us nothing about whether I do my job well, whether my remuneration is proportionate, or whether the charity uses its resources effectively. Those are fair questions, and I should expect to answer them.

Someone leading a commercial organisation of comparable size and complexity might well earn considerably more, particularly once bonuses and other benefits were included. That is useful context, although it cannot settle what a charity should pay. Trustees need to consider the responsibilities of the role, the skills required, affordability and performance, alongside fairness across the organisation. A defence of proper pay which begins and ends in the chief executive’s office would be a very poor defence indeed.

Experience matters because leadership involves judgement: knowing when to invest, when to stop something, when to listen and when to make an uncomfortable decision. It means balancing immediate needs with responsibilities that will still exist in five or ten years. But length of service is no guarantee of wisdom. Those of us paid to exercise that judgement must remain answerable for it.

The suggestion that work ceases to be charitable when someone receives a salary reveals a more fundamental misunderstanding. That confuses an individual act of generosity with the purpose of an organisation. A paid youth worker can help a young person rebuild their confidence. A paid veterinary professional can relieve an animal’s suffering. Paying them does not diminish the value or charitable purpose of that work.

Nor should the opportunity to make a career in the sector depend on having a partner, pension or private income to pay the bills. If we want people from different backgrounds to lead and work in charities, we have to make that financially possible. Commitment should not be measured by how much financial insecurity someone can endure.

I have spent much of my life volunteering and continue to do so. I also earn my living leading a charity. I recognise the value of both, and I know how closely they depend on each other. Volunteers bring knowledge, relationships, challenge and extraordinary generosity. They also deserve reliable support, clear communication, appropriate training and someone to turn to when things become difficult. Volunteering has costs, even when volunteers give their time freely.

At Cats Protection, the connection between infrastructure and purpose is practical. Veterinary care needs sound clinical arrangements. Staff need to be paid accurately, buildings maintained, supporters’ information held securely and donations accounted for properly. These arrangements can feel remote from the cat needing help today. Their value becomes clearer when a system fails, a building becomes unusable or a volunteer cannot get the advice they need.

In that sense, Cats Protection is a corporation of sorts. We have the scale, responsibilities and organisational machinery that the word suggests, and I see no reason to be embarrassed by that. In the commercial world, we recognise that organisations of different sizes can each serve a useful purpose. We should allow the same understanding in the charity sector, while asking whether our structures help us fulfil our mission and keep us responsive to those who make our work possible.

That does not mean every new system, management post or consultancy contract is a good investment. Large charities can become cumbersome. Processes can outlive their usefulness, and layers of approval can separate decision-makers from the people doing the work. Leaders have a responsibility to notice this and act. Spending more is no more an automatic sign of effectiveness than spending less.

Fundraising and reserves require similar judgement. Fundraising should be assessed against what it achieves over a sensible period, the risks involved and the way supporters are treated. Reserves can protect continuity when income falls, but need an explanation rooted in the charity’s circumstances and commitments. The Charity Commission’s guidance asks charities to explain what reserves are for and when they will be used; the Commission has also encouraged funders to contribute to core costs, including safeguarding and reserves. The ability to keep delivering deserves investment.

Yet defending this investment must not lead us to dismiss the frustration of smaller charities. A community organisation may have deep local trust, reach people others struggle to reach and respond quickly to needs that do not fit a funding programme. Its chief executive may also be its fundraiser, personnel adviser and the person who opens the building each morning. A smaller salary does not imply a smaller talent or an easier job.

Through Oxfordshire Youth, I see leadership in a different setting from Cats Protection. Jodie describes growing the organisation from an income of £250,000 to more than £2.5 million, increasing its reach from 200 to 2,000 young people and its team from fewer than ten to more than 40. That requires serious organisational capability. It also raises the question every charity should keep asking: what investment will best serve our purpose at this stage?

Growth is not the right answer for everyone. Some charities should remain small, rooted in a particular community or focused on a tightly defined need. Their ambition may be to do that work consistently well. Funders should make room for this, with proportionate applications, realistic reporting and funding that recognises the full cost of delivery. A short grant can leave a very long list of responsibilities behind it.

Larger charities have a part to play in strengthening the wider sector. At Cats Protection, part of our contribution is through organisations such as the Association of Dogs and Cats Homes, which brings rescue and rehoming organisations together around shared standards, learning and representation. Contributing time and expertise to that collective work benefits more than our own charity. These organisations need support too; collaboration cannot run indefinitely on spare moments.

We should also ask whether we listen properly to smaller organisations, share useful expertise and give partners fair recognition and resources. Collaboration should make their work easier, rather than add another organisation’s administrative demands. Responsible partnership needs safeguards, but those safeguards should be proportionate.

Larger charities can also sustain research, policy expertise and relationships with government that would be difficult for a small organisation to maintain on its own. At Cats Protection, advocacy is part of our responsibility to cats. Helping an individual animal matters enormously; influencing the conditions that leave animals vulnerable can prevent suffering on a much wider scale. Work on legislation, public policy and responsible ownership belongs alongside the care provided in our centres and foster homes.

That work is less easily photographed than a successful rehoming, and its results may take years. It also requires care in attributing success: policy changes usually owe much to a coalition of organisations, campaigners and people with direct experience. A large charity should use its access to bring that experience into the room, and be willing to support a shared achievement without insisting on owning it. Having a louder voice brings a responsibility to listen.

I am now, somewhat to my surprise, one of the sector’s elder statespeople. That brings a responsibility which extends beyond the charity that employs me. I feel a responsibility to explain how our sector works, challenge lazy assumptions and support those finding their way into leadership. I also need to listen to colleagues whose experience is different from mine, especially those leading organisations with far fewer resources. Years in the job should make me more useful to others, and more conscious of what I still have to learn.

Our sector needs local knowledge and national reach, specialist organisations and broad networks, volunteers and paid staff. Their contributions overlap and strengthen one another. Castigating the largest charities misses that interdependence, just as assuming that a familiar national name must always offer the best answer would miss it.

Donors are entitled to ask difficult questions. Many give from limited household budgets, and they deserve clear answers rather than irritation or a lecture about complexity. We should explain what things cost, acknowledge where we fall short and show what has changed as a result of their support. We should also be honest about the work whose benefits take longer to become visible: prevention, education, advocacy and the patient building of trust.

Jodie is right to challenge the expectation that effectiveness can be sustained on goodwill alone. I am happy to defend investment in the people and organisations that make charitable work possible, including experienced, properly paid leadership. Alongside my colleagues and trustees, I must also be prepared to demonstrate what that investment achieves for cats and the people who care about them.

Similar Posts