| |

Give young people a first chance. Then stay with them.

An empty café ready for the working day, with an apron and open notebook beside the coffee machine.

As Chief Executive of Cats Protection, I read Alan Milburn’s report on young people and work, published today, with a practical question: will this help us give more young people a decent start? Our shops and cat centres offer opportunities to learn, take responsibility and do something useful for animals. We also have colleagues who need time and support to help someone learn the ropes. I want to know what these proposals mean for both.

You might wonder why an animal welfare chief executive is getting his paws into youth unemployment. For someone who loves animals, helping cats can be a very good reason to get involved. We benefit from what young people bring; we owe them opportunities worth having. My years as a teacher, Scout and Chair of Oxfordshire Youth make me fairly demanding about that.

Milburn’s report, From a Welfare State to a Working State, recognises that improving employability achieves precious little without jobs to go to. Quite. You can polish a CV until you can see your face in it; somebody still has to offer you a job.

My dear friend Howard Williamson, Emeritus Professor at the University of South Wales and a longstanding authority on European youth policy, made this point ahead of publication. Howard has spent fifty years working with young people, researching their lives and helping shape youth policy. We should listen when he says the jobs must be there, and the opportunities must make sense to those being asked to take them up.

And can we have a word about NEET? I have never liked “not in education, employment or training”. It tells us nothing about someone’s abilities, ambitions or the barriers they face. Call them “a NEET” and an administrative category becomes their identity. I would be fairly cheesed off if that were how people described me.

Perhaps LEET — “Looking for Employment, Education or Training” — would be better. At least there is some hope in it. It will not fit everyone; illness, caring responsibilities or finding somewhere safe to live may need attention first. Changing an acronym will not create a job, but I would rather begin with what someone hopes to do.

Milburn proposes a Youth Opportunity Service, named advisers and guarantees of support and opportunity. Where work is realistically possible with support, a paid six-month job would become a backstop after twelve months. I welcome that ambition. My questions are about what happens when things get difficult.

Recently, speaking with Hatch participants through the KFC Youth Foundation, I was struck by what they said about supportive managers and feeling valued. Having someone take them seriously had mattered. Through Oxfordshire Youth, and during my High Sheriff year themed “Hearing the Young Unheard”, I have seen how much depends on trusted adults who keep turning up.

So an adviser needs time, a manageable caseload and access to help that actually exists. When someone has a rotten week or a placement starts going wrong, somebody needs to pick up the phone. Good youth work takes patience; trust does not arrive with the appointment letter.

Employers have homework too, myself included. Does an entry-level job really need previous experience? Does our application process tell us whether someone could do the work? Have we equipped their manager to support a beginner? We cannot complain that young people lack experience while making it unnecessarily difficult to acquire any.

At Cats Protection, we already have age-appropriate volunteering opportunities in our shops and centres, with considerable enthusiasm for creating more where we get the support right. There are first jobs too. Government could help employers offer more through funding for supervision, travel, adjustments and support after someone starts. The first day is only the beginning.

The proposed thirteen-week civic service programme includes structured volunteering with additional financial support. Scouting and The Duke of Edinburgh’s Award show what is possible. Doing DofE can help young people learn to plan ahead, work as a team, take responsibility and keep going when things get tricky. They practise turning up when they said they would, listening to other people and doing their bit without someone forever nudging them along. Those are useful habits for a first job, and for life generally. Confidence grows when you discover, by having a go, that you can do more than you thought.

But charities cannot magic up good placements. Preparation, supervision and safeguarding cost money. Please do not give us a national programme, a warm handshake and the assumption that we will find the rest down the back of the sofa. Volunteering must also be a meaningful choice with somewhere to go afterwards, never a substitute for a paid vacancy or a holding pen for young people.

The teacher in me welcomes better preparation for working life, although I have reservations about another school “ready-for-work” measure. Useful work experience should not depend on Mum or Dad knowing someone. Equally, books, music, curiosity and citizenship belong in education too. So does learning to ask awkward questions. I rather hope we are still encouraging those.

Benefits are where my enthusiasm becomes more cautious. Milburn proposes replacing under-25s’ existing health and disability benefit arrangements with a Youth Allowance and different disability support. Persistent refusal to engage could mean losing the allowance, subject to safeguards. But how reliably will the system distinguish refusal from being unable to manage what is asked?

I am neurodiverse. Being capable does not mean every process works for you, or that explaining the difficulty is easy. A missed appointment may have an explanation that takes time to uncover. Believing in someone’s potential should make us more willing to adjust our approach, rather than tell them they ought to be coping by now.

Action for Children warns that income reductions could increase poverty and make participation harder. People still need to eat, heat their homes and pay for the bus while support is arranged. The report says local support should precede benefit changes. That needs independent scrutiny, with disabled young people helping judge whether the help works. Ministers must explain who could lose out, how they will be protected and how wrong decisions can be challenged.

There is a distinction worth keeping in mind about the ambition too. The analytical annex models a NEET rate of 6.8%; the headline aspiration is around 5%. We should be honest about the gap. I want a funded plan, clear responsibilities and progress we can examine, with young people involved even when their answers are inconvenient.

My test is straightforward: if this were a young person I knew, would I be happy with the opportunity? Would the work be worthwhile, the expectations fair and the money enough to live on? Would someone notice if things went wrong? There is much here worth getting behind. Giving someone a first chance matters enormously; staying alongside them while they find their feet is part of the job too.


Sources checked on 17 November 2026. These are proposals in an independent review, rather than enacted changes. Education, health and delivery arrangements must also be read in the context of devolution.

Alan Milburn, From a Welfare State to a Working State — full report, especially chapters 3–8.
Action for Children’s response.
ITV News, report and funding summary.
Analytical annex, especially sections 1–4.

Similar Posts