Listening to Alan Milburn being interviewed by Laura Kuenssberg on the BBC this morning, I found myself thinking about a young person trying to get a Saturday job. Much of the discussion ahead of his review, expected on Tuesday, concerns benefits, ill health and the nearly one million young people who are not in education, employment or training. Those are urgent questions. But we also need to ask what happens earlier, when a teenager first tries to find someone willing to give them a chance.
By the time a young person has spent months outside education and employment, several opportunities to help may already have been missed. The first rejection might have come years before, from a shop, café or other local employer unable to offer a few hours’ work. One rejection is ordinary enough; repeated across a community, and then across the country, those closed doors begin to matter.
I approach this from two perspectives. As Chief Executive of Cats Protection, I lead an organisation whose cat centres and charity shops offer opportunities for volunteering and paid employment, including roles that can provide an introduction to working life. As Chair of Oxfordshire Youth, I am concerned with the support young people need to develop confidence, exercise responsibility and find their place in their communities. These are personal reflections, but both roles make it difficult to regard the present debate simply as a question of what the benefits system should pay.
A Saturday job can look rather insignificant from the other end of a career. A few hours sorting stock, helping customers or carrying out routine tasks hardly sounds like a major intervention in someone’s future. Yet it provides a setting in which much of what we call “life skills” becomes practical. You have to arrive when you said you would, listen to instructions, work alongside people you did not choose, ask for help and put things right when you make a mistake. Other people depend on your contribution; gradually, you discover that you have something useful to offer.
The opportunities to acquire that experience have been shrinking for a long time. Back in 2015, the UK Commission for Employment and Skills reported that the proportion of 16- and 17-year-old students combining study with work had fallen from 42% in 1997 to 18% in 2014. More recently, the Work Foundation found that advertised starter vacancies fell by almost half between 2016–17 and 2025–26. That broader category extends beyond teenage jobs, but it helps explain why finding a first foothold has become so difficult.
We should be careful about responding with nostalgia. Earlier generations did not enjoy universally supportive workplaces, and some young people were poorly paid, badly treated or expected to work hours that interfered with school. Protections exist for good reasons. Nevertheless, we have allowed opportunities for manageable, supervised employment to diminish without ensuring that something equally accessible takes their place.
From an employer’s perspective, the difficulties are real. Taking on someone who has never worked means making time to explain, demonstrate, supervise and encourage. A busy manager must fit that around everything else for which they are responsible. In a charity, that time has to be found alongside delivering the cause and making careful use of donated money. Willingness matters, but willingness alone does not create supervisory capacity.
The wider economic pressures make that harder. In the CBI’s October employment survey, 44% of businesses said rising recruitment and onboarding costs were pushing them towards experienced recruits. More than a third said pressure on training budgets was leading them to seek people who needed no additional training for entry-level roles. An employer may understand perfectly well why a young person needs a chance, while concluding that their own organisation cannot currently afford to provide it.
For younger teenagers there are further complications. Below school-leaving age, employers must navigate restrictions on hours and duties, alongside local permit arrangements. In Oxfordshire, an employer must apply for a permit, provide a risk assessment and obtain the school’s signature. Children can work only two hours on a Sunday, and employment in a commercial kitchen is prohibited. Each requirement has a rationale; collectively, they can make employing a schoolchild a substantial undertaking for a small business seeking a little weekend help.
Government should examine how that system works in practice. It should be possible to protect children and provide a clear, straightforward route for employers offering suitable work. Consistent guidance, accessible advice and proportionate administration would help. So would challenging assumptions that employing anyone under 18 is necessarily too difficult or unsafe.
Milburn’s interview was encouraging in recognising that employers need practical help. He discussed wage subsidies and the additional support some young people require when they enter work. He also resisted the suggestion that young people should lose employment protections or have their minimum wage cut. That seems a sensible starting point: help employers meet the cost of offering a good first opportunity, while maintaining the standards a young worker should be able to expect.
We need precision in the debate about costs. Higher employer National Insurance bills can squeeze an organisation’s overall staffing budget, but employers generally already pay a zero rate on under-21s’ earnings up to the relevant threshold. Further support should address the costs that remain, particularly training, supervision and helping a new starter settle into working life.
Volunteering offers another valuable introduction, but similar pressures apply. Some organisations have decided that they cannot take on the additional responsibilities involved. Age UK Waltham Forest’s published safeguarding policy, for example, excludes under-18 volunteers for that reason. Hampstead Community Centre has stopped accepting them in its After School Club, explaining the implications for safeguarding, supervision and staffing, although it says it will explore opportunities outside its childcare settings. These are specific local decisions, rather than evidence that entire national organisations have closed their doors. They nevertheless show how opportunities can disappear.
I understand why organisations reach those conclusions. Safeguarding is a serious responsibility, and nobody should offer a placement they cannot support properly. But the cumulative effect should concern us. Every organisation may have a defensible reason for saying no; the young person is still left with nowhere to go.
At Cats Protection, we already have some age-appropriate volunteering opportunities in our shops and centres, and there is considerable enthusiasm for creating many more. We are committed to keeping access open wherever we can, while getting the support right for young volunteers and the colleagues welcoming them. That means making sure people have the time, resources and confidence to provide a good experience.
An interest in cats can be a very good starting point. It gives a young person a reason to come through the door, something to talk about and a purpose beyond improving their CV. Through useful activity, they can get to know supportive adults, become part of a team and discover abilities they may not previously have recognised in themselves.
Volunteering must remain voluntary, and it cannot substitute for paid employment when someone needs an income. We must also consider who can afford to participate. Travel costs, caring responsibilities and pressure to earn can put even a welcoming opportunity out of reach. A route that works only for young people whose families can subsidise it will leave many of those who need it most behind.
My perspective as Chair of Oxfordshire Youth leads me back to the importance of relationships. An opportunity may exist on paper, but a young person still needs the confidence to approach it, the means to get there and someone to turn to if the first day goes badly. Youth workers can help make those connections. They can recognise progress that an application form misses and help a young person translate experience from the rest of their life into something an employer understands.
That work needs sustained investment. A referral, a website or a single appointment cannot do everything that a trusted adult may achieve over months. Nor should we wait until someone has disengaged before deciding that the relationship was worth funding. Youth work belongs in the government’s response to this challenge, including the work that helps young people remain connected to education, their communities and their own ambitions.
The discussion of mental health and neurodiversity needs similar care. I am neurodiverse myself; I know that a diagnosis does not describe the limits of someone’s contribution. It may, however, help explain what support or adjustments will allow them to contribute. Government should expect ambition from services and employers, while taking disability and ill health seriously. Support must respond to the person and their circumstances.
This is where some of the commentary around Milburn’s report troubles me. The Times is right to draw attention to wasted human potential and the need for action. But descriptions of young people retreating into bedrooms and screens can too easily become the whole explanation. They tell us little about repeated rejection, inaccessible transport, unsuitable recruitment or the experience of trying to work while unwell. We need to understand withdrawal well enough to help someone move beyond it.
One of the most useful parts of Milburn’s interview concerned part-time work. He recognised that five, six or ten hours a week could be a meaningful step, and argued that the benefits system should support that progress. I hope that principle survives into the government’s response. For someone rebuilding confidence or managing a health condition, a small number of reliable hours may be a considerable achievement. Policy should make the next step easier to take.
When the report is published, I want ministers to respond with a funded plan that reaches beyond welfare administration. It should help employers offer first jobs, support the people supervising new starters, make suitable work easier to arrange for under-18s and under-16s, and give youth organisations the stability to build lasting relationships. It should also help charities keep volunteering accessible, through clear guidance and practical support. Young people themselves should help shape that response, including those whose experience of existing services has been disappointing.
Employers have responsibilities as well. Those of us leading organisations should examine whether our recruitment processes recognise potential, whether we ask unnecessarily for previous experience, and whether we could create a manageable role with the right support. That challenge applies to charities as much as to commercial businesses, and to my own organisation as much as anyone else’s.
We will need to read Milburn’s recommendations carefully before judging the whole package. His warning this morning that meaningful change will take sustained investment deserves to be heard alongside the arguments about benefits and obligations. Government must now show how it will make participation possible in the ordinary places where working lives begin: a shop, a café, a charity, a local team with someone willing and able to explain the job.
I would like more young people to reach their first application with a little experience, some confidence and an adult prepared to give them a reference. Achieving that will require action long before they appear in a statistic about youth unemployment. A few hours on a Saturday would be a good place to start.
